Healthy Eating Paradox

Quick show of hands: how many people out there enjoy the “Jay-walking” segments on The Tonight Show? If you’re not familiar with it, this is where Jay Leno hits the streets with a microphone and asks average people simple questions. For example, “In what year did the Battle of Beroia result in the disappearance of the Pechenegs as an independent force?” The poor interviewee invariably replies with something really stupid, like 1124, when everybody knows it was 1122.

All right, I’m kidding. Usually it’s more along the lines of, “Who was the first president?” which typically fetches a response of, “Abraham Lincoln?” (Hey, could be worse. At least they picked an actual president.)

I imagine if Jay asked people, “Which fast food restaurant would be the better choice for a dieter, McDonald’s or Subway?” most of his victims would reply, “Abraham Lincoln?” Okay … most of them would definitely say “Subway” and ironically, they’d be just as wrong as those who picked Lincoln.

Wait a minute, Charlie … did you say that right? Subway is the wrong answer for the dieter? You’re crazy. Jarad lost eight thousand pounds at Subway. They have forty-seven sandwiches with forty-seven or fewer calories. They sell cookies, that when broken apart, actually have negative calories. I went to a Subway one day, ordered lunch, and actually left two pant sizes smaller. You can’t mean that, Charlie.

Well, according to a study published in the Journal of Consumer Research last October, people ate on average 131% more calories when they thought they were eating healthful alternatives. Ironically, this was on top of the fact that the “healthy” meal already had 50% more calories than the “unhealthy” meal. What does this mean? It means we’re stupid, that’s what.

My advice to everyone (including myself) is simple: use your head. Just because something is “healthy” doesn’t mean it’s free. Pigging out on healthy entrees in a restaurant is no different from eating an entire box of fat free cookies or chowing down a ginormous bucket of fried chicken just because it was cooked in oils containing zero grams of trans fats. Don’t fall for it … or you just might end up on Jay Leno one day.



2 Responses to “Healthy Eating Paradox”

Jennifer said
on
August 29, 2008 at 8:00 am

I agree with you Charlie. If you ever compare a box of reduced fat cheese its for example, with the regular, the difference is so miniscule that you may as well get the regular and then you wouldn’t eat as much. Because it is low fat, you think, this is fantastic, I can eat more when in fact the calories are exactly the same! I think they should ban low fat foods altogether, because the calories are what matters the most!
http://www.slim-shoppin.com

Back to the Fridge » The 100 Calorie Trap said
on
September 4, 2008 at 12:53 am

[…] study says. And, of course, when we hear “diet” we think “free”. (Refer to last Friday’s post for a related […]

Leave a Reply. All the cool kids are doing it.

Comment:

Three Benefits of Exercise

August 28th, 2008

Basically speaking, I don’t like exer- cising. I know that’s absolutely the wrong frame of mind. I also know this statement isn’t going to inspire anyone to get up off their rumps and run twenty-six miles tomorrow. But since this blog is a no-nonsense zone (well, once you discount all the nonsense) then I must […]

Read the full post | 1 Comment »

Perspective

August 27th, 2008

I like humor. This, if you’ve ever spent ten minutes with me, is readily obvious. I believe it’s a grossly underrated tool and for those of you who’ve followed my writing, you know first hand that it’s my weapon of choice in our collective struggle with weight control. I simply enjoy writing things that make […]

Read the full post | 2 Comments »

Diet Vernors Ginger Ale

August 26th, 2008

It’s a fair bet to say that most of us were raised on sugar drinks. And with good reason. What better way to keep a growing kid’s mind sharp and focused than through a daily dose of eight pounds of pure cane sugar dissolved in ice water? I particularly remember summers growing up, my mom […]

Read the full post | Comments Off on Diet Vernors Ginger Ale

Here We Go Again

August 25th, 2008

Welcome to the all new Back to the Fridge. If you’ve been to this site before, and things are looking a little strange around here today, visit the What’s New? page for an overview, as well as links to all the old content. If you’re new (or you really don’t care) then by all means […]

Read the full post | 2 Comments »

New is Old and Old is New

August 24th, 2008

This new URL (http://version1.backtothefridge.com) is now the permanent archive of the former Back to the Fridge site. The old URL (http://www.backtothefridge.com) is now the new site. If you’ve run across this new old site looking for the new new site then you need to go to the new old site. If, on the other hand, […]

Read the full post | Comments Off on New is Old and Old is New

Where the Heck is Charlie?

August 19th, 2008

Okay, okay … I haven’t posted since August 5. (And I haven’t had a good post, really, since July 30.) But that will all be changing soon. Get ready for Back to the Fridge 2: Electric Boogaloo. Next Monday, August 25, 2008, I’ll be re-launching the site. It’ll have a new look, a new purpose, […]

Read the full post | 2 Comments »

The Women’s Magazine Diet

August 5th, 2008

This is the third of three reviews of popular diets. To the untrained eye, the Womenโ€™s Magazine Diet looks strikingly similar to the Fad Diet. However, a closer look will reveal important differences. This diet routinely begins with an article called THE TRUTH ABOUT THE FAD DIET. This in-depth piece of journalism exposes the lies […]

Read the full post | Comments Off on The Women’s Magazine Diet

The Fad Diet

August 4th, 2008

This is the second of three reviews of popular diets. Since the Regular Diet apparently wasn’t making anyone bucket loads of money, the Fad Diet was created. The primary goal of the diet is to get ten million people to buy the book. The primary goal of the book is to get you, the consumer, […]

Read the full post | Comments Off on The Fad Diet

The Regular Diet

August 3rd, 2008

This is the first of three reviews of popular diets. Most of us grew up with this diet. It invariably takes the shape of some regular geometric object and recommends you eat some foods more than others. The proportions change in response to food industry lobbying, so it’s hard to tell what’s good for you […]

Read the full post | Comments Off on The Regular Diet